SEO has evolved, and you need AEO and GEO to fully optimize your website. That’s a neat story. But the wrong one.

The brokerage industry loves a tidy timeline. First came SEO. You optimized your website and created landing pages. Then AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and now GEO (Generative Engine Optimization). Each one is sold as the next step, with its own checklist and tools.

The truth is that these aren’t three versions of the same discipline. SEO worked because of how search behaved. That behavior is going, going, gone.

Here’s Why SEO Worked

Google wanted to help you find information in the most convenient and fastest way possible. For this, its algorithms worked on keywords. Ten people in the same city searching ‘best forex broker’ saw largely the same SERP (search engine results page). If your brokerage ranked #1 for a keyword, it ranked #1 irrespective of who was searching. You could say it was a more egalitarian approach!

That made SEO a game you could play and measure. There was one target, one position and one report. You knew where you stood on Monday and whether you’d moved by Friday.

What Really Changed with LLMs?

An LLM doesn’t care about keywords. Are marketing agencies telling you to optimize for prompts instead? But here’s the thing. LLMs change their answers depending on who is asking the question. That’s because they have ‘context’.

The SERP was the same for you and the world’s richest person. It was the same whether you were new to trading or a professional trader. But an LLM has context. It reads the full question, the earlier messages in the conversation and what it already knows about you through previous chats. It considers your location, level of experience and what you seem to want.

So, a beginner asking about trading platforms and a scalper with five years of history can type nearly the same sentence and get different answers.

The answer is also generated fresh each time, not pulled from a ranked list. Ask the same question twice and the brokerages mentioned can change.

So, ask yourself this: What exactly are you optimizing for?

There’s no fixed keyword and no shared results page. There is no “position one” to take and defend. The goal post keeps changing and you don’t know what to measure.

The AEO and GEO Checklist Problem

Much of what is sold as AEO or GEO is SEO under a new label. It’s the same tricks, with “optimized for ChatGPT” on the box. Some of it is harmless, such as adding FAQs and tightening headings. None of it is a strategy.

Be especially careful with “AI visibility scores”. Most run a fixed set of prompts and report whether your brand appeared. That is a sample of a few queries from a system that gives different answers to different people. It’s a snapshot, not a ranking.

So, What Actually Works?

Don’t ask, “How do I get picked for this prompt?” Ask what the model asks: “Who can I trust enough to put in front of my human?”

An LLM isn’t hunting for a keyword match. It’s trying not to give a wrong or harmful answer, so it looks for sources it can believe and checks them against each other. That points to four things.

Build credibility: Get real
Make it easy to verify your brokerage. That could mean mentioning your licenses and regulator registrations on important pages of your website. Name the people in your team. Be transparent about pricing, spreads and fees. Share testimonials and mention your track record.

Get cited: LLMs corroborate
A claim that appears only on your own site is not as creditworthy for LLMs as it being mentioned on other sites. LLMs look for the same facts in review sites, financial media, comparison sites, forums and industry bodies. Digital PR, genuine reviews, and expert commentary are valuable, as they become inputs for the model to judge you. If nobody outside your company says you’re good, the model has no reason to say so either.

Be machine-readable: Text takes priority
Images, infographics, screenshots and videos are better for humans. LLMs can ‘read’ crawlers are lazy. They bypass these to explain concepts better to hIf a machine can’t parse your content, it can’t use it. That means clean, crawlable pages with a clear structure. It means schema markup for your organisation, products, FAQs and reviews. Pricing and account details should sit in real HTML tables, not locked inside images, PDFs or heavy scripts. And don’t block AI crawlers by accident. Check your robots.txt.

4. Be consistent everywhere.
Your company name, licences, account types and fees should match across your site, your profiles, your listings and your press coverage. When sources contradict each other, the model gets less sure of you, and an uncertain model plays it safe by recommending someone else.

5. Answer real trader questions properly.
Thin, keyword-stuffed pages don’t earn citations. Depth, original data and clear explanations do. Write the content a serious trader would actually bookmark, and others will quote it.

Why this matters more in broking
Trading is a high-stakes category: money, risk and regulation. AI systems are cautious here, and they should be. They lean on authority and avoid brands with unresolved complaints, because they read the complaints too.

For a broker, a weak reputation doesn’t just cost a ranking. It can get you described negatively in the answer itself. Trust is the whole game. A compliance reminder: no inflated performance claims. They hurt your credibility with models as well as with regulators.

Measure differently
Rank tracking made sense when there was a rank. Now track:

  • How often your brand is mentioned across many varied prompts, not five fixed ones
  • The sentiment and accuracy of those mentions
  • Which sources the AI cites when it talks about you
  • Direct and branded search growth
  • Referral traffic coming from AI platforms

Treat the results as trends, not positions.

The bottom line
This isn’t a new channel with a new trick. It’s the oldest idea in marketing wearing new clothes: reputation. Be credible, be consistent and be talked about by people who aren’t you. Then make it easy for machines to find and read.

Algorithms will keep changing. What they reward is a brand that’s actually worth recommending, and the best way to be recommended by AI is to be worth recommending.

A few things to tighten before you publish:

  • Add data: I’ve used no statistics, since I can’t verify any. One or two sourced figures, such as the growth of AI referral traffic, would strengthen it.
  • Add an example: a short before-and-after from one of your clients would show you’ve done this, not just written about it.
  • Check the compliance line: adjust it to the regulators your broker clients operate under.

I can also make it punchier, cut it to about 600 words for LinkedIn, or write a version aimed at broker CMOs.